Best Pony Roommate (mane Six)

I would Pick Applejack for sure.

Rainbow Dash, because she seems like a fun person to have around.

If I could have two, Octavia and Vinyl. If I had to choose between the two, Octavia. I do love some serious class and classical music.

Harold_Genhi wrote:If I could have two, Octavia and Vinyl. If I had to choose between the two, Octavia. I do love some serious class and classical music.

umm out of the mane six

Pinkie Pie would get on my nerves in 10 seconds flat.

Twilight Sparkle would annoy me to no end with her OCD.

Rarity could be tolerable if she didn't try to constantly change the interior decoration to suit -her- vision of what should be. My room, my mess.

Rainbow Dash might be fun to hang with, but I dread the idea of having to share a house with her.

Fluttershy... That could be a maybe, but she'd need to assert herself. I'd want a roommate, not a doormat.

Applejack, her ? She would probably try to wake me up early in the morning on the weekends to do whatever needs to be done in her opinion. And I get the feeling trying to talk with her about what needs to be done and how would be met with stubborness.



Fluttershy might win this one.

Considering how antisocial I am 90% of the time, I'd probably pick Fluttershy, because she'd be the easiest to ignore and pretend she's not there.

I'm not so much antisocial as I'm independent and territorial.

I just got the sneaking suspicion you're actually a cat

I cannot confirm nor deny this statement.

I'd say that it's the reason you're so smug, but then I remembered you're French

Do note the two are not mutually exclusive.

A smug Frenchman? Why, I never.....

Yeah, either AJ or Twilight (not the alicorn, that still didn't happen in my head).

While Applejack may not be my favorite member of the mane cast

I would pick her as a roommate because she would probably be the only one who would pay her share of the rent on time every time.

CamoBadger wrote:Yeah, either AJ or Twilight (not the alicorn, that still didn't happen in my head).

Twilight comes in second behind Pinkie in "just absolutly hell no"

The only characters I wouldn't find particularly annoying would be Applejack and Twilight. I value honesty and reliability, and Applejack isn't very talkative.
Twilight would be interesting to actually talk to, unlike just about any of the others, and she's tidy.

And just a reminder to those that are 'anti-social', look it up, because it doesn't mean avoidance of socialization, but rather a disregard for society and people in general. I'm pretty sure you mean 'asocial'.

I didn't choose twilight because I knew that would include board for her assistant and she would also have her own experiments going on, add to this the mess she leaves behind while in the middle of her studies and such, I think she wouldn't suit me, I am a bit messy, but I try to keep it confined. Not to mention her particular OCD habits. I also turned down rarity because she is absolutely absorbed in her work and can be a bit messy in the process, and god forbit I should pick up after her, not to mention my asocial behaviors would make it difficult between the two of us, we'd get along I think, but her propensity for rapid fire talk and sweet manipulation is a bit disturbing. Fluttershy was one I considered, but then again I have a tendency to push folks pretty hard, same reason with rainbow, i push buttons, although rainbow would be a close second. Pinkie Pie we do share interests in the culinary field but i am pretty sure with her over the top social outgoing behavior would clash with my own rather closed off bits. Not to mention I don't want to just have her pop out of a corner on me while I am showering to ask something. Applejack is someone who reminds me of tracy true to her obligations, but still flexible enough to be a bit spur of the moment, she's used to living with other folks and her work schedule would keep the two of us out of each other's hair. Her greatest flaw would probably be a few differences of opinion and the two of us can be mighty stubborn, but i think her down to earth is just a bit more in favor.

the reasoning for my choices. although getting chores done would be bothersome for sure when it comes to twilight, she'd probably have it all scheduled and then sticky notes...

Twilight and Sticky notes, that would be an interesting fanfiction./

Apple Jack. Simple yet fun. Can whip up some deserts too :D.

Second would be Twilly w/ Spike

I also want to bed Formis

Now that's a tough one, let's see...

Twilight, I wouldn't mind her passion for reading as I do read a lot myself, even though I preffer fiction. At least the library would be evenly stocked. And she would probably be the most interesting one to debate with. Her paranoid-neurotic attitude towards the smallest of issues however... And also depends if Spike counts too, that'd be one roommate too many. (How ironic)

Pinkie Pie... No. Her super-hyperactive-social behavior kills any chance of me accepting her as a roommate, I like my room peaceful and quiet and possibly devoid of crowds of people.

Rarity, well, depends if she would try to constantly put me in dresses and stuff. We both like organized chaos in our things so that wouldn't be much of an issue, unless she wouldn't like my organized chaos and tried to re-arrange it, or prettify every little thing.

RD I could probably put up with, given that most of the time she would probably be outside, training her flying skills. Unless she would try to drag me to watch her or something, or boast too loud to ignore. :D

AJ wouldn't be that bad unless she would wake me up early in the morning, I like waking up when I feel like it, not with the sun. :P

And Fluttershy, well I can't really say anything bad about her, she certainly wouldn't get on my nerves in any way an I'm sure she'd warm up to me after a time.

Rainbow Dash. She likes to fly, I like to fly. I need someone to help motivate me for PT, she's always doing something.

I'm also thinking of saddle designs so she could fly me places. My preferred outfit for such an occasion would be a loincloth, war-ax, and white tophat just fucking because.

Fluttershy because not only would having a pegasus be the best, but also because I'd be able to get lots of hugs off her, I reckon.
I mean, yeah, Pinkie is the cuddly happy one, but Flutters would keep the place clean and I imagine she'd be awkward about hugs at first, but soon calm down and come to love the cuddles.